The Discovery 


The Discovery is a new film distributed by Netflix and only viewable on their streaming service. There is quite a lot of talk at the moment about how companies like Netflix are going to kill the cinema industry. The worry is that if movies are picked up by companies such as this and immediately released for home viewing then people won’t want to go to the picture houses anymore. Sure, Everyman has sofas and beer but so do most living rooms. Some people even have HD projectors and surround sound. Still I don’t think the theatre chains need to be worried just yet. Judging by this new release, along with those Netflix Adam Sandler movies, it isn’t just the home screens that have reduced dimensions; everything about the films being put out this way is just a little bit small-scale. (Multi award winning Beasts of No Nation is the possible exception to this rule and it’s simultaneous home and theatre release did lead to high streaming figures and tiny box office but it remains an outlier.)


It isn’t that this is a bad film, not at all. It’s that it is very very nearly a really good one. Watching The Discovery you get a sense that with a few different people behind it it could have really stood out from the multiplex crowd. The clever story revolves around the scientific discovery that there is an after life and how the suicide rate has skyrocketed as a result. Robert Redford plays the man behind this incredible realisation and Jason Segel is his sceptical son. Highly celebrated and twice Oscar nominated Rooney Mara also features as a mystery woman with a possible agenda of her own. It isn’t the cast that are wanting though, it’s the direction. With David Fincher at the helm, or Denis Villeneuve or Nicolas Winding Refn, The Discovery could have been so much more suspenseful and the chemistry between the leads so much better. The reveal of what is really going on after people die should have been an astonishing revelation, the twists ought to have been exciting, but as it is it all just trundles along to a poetic but lacklustre ending. With a really good director this would have been better and would have almost certainly seen the inside of cinemas. As it is it’s a typical example of what was once known as ‘a straight to video gem’, good but a little lacking.


I don’t want to be too harsh on Charlie McDowell (who incidentally is Rooney Mara’s husband and the son of Malcolm McDowell and Mary Steenburgen, who also appears in the film). He writes the film as well as directing and the script is strong. McDowell will probably do interesting things in the future but he’s not a player yet. The conceit of the movie is intriguing and mercifully avoids becoming a horror film which it may well have done with studio interference. It does feel derivative of a range of things from Twelve Monkeys to Black Mirror though and if you’ve seen a lot of these types of movies then the denouement is satisfying but not a surprise. It also has a chunk of exposition at the end from a character that wouldn’t really have the knowledge to explain these things quite so easily. Villeneuve would have never have used such a clumsy narrative short cut. 


I enjoyed The Discovery. It isn’t going to change history but see it now if it sounds like your sort of thing, there’s certainly no need to wait for the DVD release.



Is this one for the kids?
Because it is streaming The Discovery has not been rated by the BBFC but on Netflix it is listed as a 15. It isn’t scary or particularly disturbing but it does have themes heavily centred around death and mortality.

One thought on “The Discovery 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s